An Ankara court on Wednesday sentenced nine of the 12 defendants in the criminal case over the CHP’s 38th Ordinary Congress, including jailed Istanbul mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu, to two years and one month in prison each, NTV, Cumhuriyet, Sabah and Yeni Akit reported. The Ankara 26th Criminal Court of First Instance acquitted the other three defendants, among them İzmir Metropolitan Mayor Cemil Tugay, according to Cumhuriyet, Sabah, Ekotürk and Velev. The ruling ended the trial’s tenth session, covered in our hearing report.
The case concerns alleged irregularities at the congress held on 4-5 November 2023, at which Özgür Özel defeated Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu for the party leadership, NTV and Cumhuriyet reported. Prosecutors alleged that delegates were offered money, jobs or candidacies to vote for Özel, NTV and Cumhuriyet reported; the defendants deny this.
Update, 18 November, 19:30: First reaction from YENİ Parti: YENİ Parti Group Deputy Chairman Murat Emir said on social media that with the verdict “the law was once again torn down”, Cumhuriyet, Başka Gazete and Haberler.com (ANKA) reported. Emir argued that colleagues who stood firm were given political bans while those who pledged loyalty to keep their seats were acquitted, and said the congress and its delegates’ will had been clean, according to Cumhuriyet and Haberler.com (ANKA). He added that being counted as politically banned before history was “a thousand times more honourable” than being cleared, Cumhuriyet, Başka Gazete and Haberler.com (ANKA) reported. The court acquitted the three other defendants for lack of sufficient evidence, ANKA and Cumhuriyet reported. The reports carried no statement from Özgür Özel, İmamoğlu’s lawyers or the AK Party, and did not say whether an appeal had been filed; the political bans apply only once the verdict is final, Başka Gazete and Cumhuriyet noted. (Sources: Cumhuriyet, Başka Gazete, Haberler.com / ANKA, ANKA.)
Who was convicted and who was acquitted
Besides İmamoğlu, those sentenced include Özgür Çelik, the Istanbul provincial chair of Özel’s new YENİ Parti, and Nihat Yeşiltaş, the party’s Bursa provincial chair, Cumhuriyet and Velev reported. Detained Beşiktaş mayor Rıza Akpolat and Bursa Osmangazi mayor Erkan Aydın were also convicted, according to Cumhuriyet and TR724. The remaining four convicted defendants were a former CHP provincial chair and three congress delegates, according to Cumhuriyet and TR724.
Tugay, who recently moved from the CHP to the ruling AK Party, was acquitted along with two other defendants, Cumhuriyet and Velev reported. The court found no evidence beyond doubt that the three had taken part in the alleged offence, according to Cumhuriyet and TR724.
Sabah and NTV described the charge as rigging a vote, while the prosecutor had sought punishment under the Political Parties Law, according to NTV and Velev.
The political ban and what happens next
The court applied Article 53 of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK) to the convicted defendants, NTV, Sabah, Ekotürk and Yeni Akit reported. This article automatically strips people sentenced to prison of certain rights while the sentence is being served, including the right to vote and stand for election, according to Sabah, NTV and Yeni Akit.
The ban does not take effect immediately: it applies only once the verdict becomes final, NTV, Cumhuriyet and Yeni Akit reported. None of the reports said that the court had deferred the pronouncement of the verdict (known in Türkiye as HAGB) or converted the prison terms into a fine or another measure.
A first-instance verdict in Türkiye can be challenged at a regional appeals court (istinaf) and then at the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) before it becomes final, BirGün and Cumhuriyet noted in an earlier case. In September İmamoğlu was given an identical two-year, one-month term and a political ban in a separate insult case over remarks about a former Tuzla mayor, a ruling his lawyers have appealed, according to BirGün, Bianet and Cumhuriyet.
Statements in court
Before the verdict, İmamoğlu’s lawyer Çağlar Çağlayan told the court he rejected the prosecutor’s opinion and asked for his client’s acquittal, Cumhuriyet and Sabah reported. The reports carried no statements from the parties after the verdict.
The case runs in parallel with a civil ruling that annulled the same congress on grounds of "absolute nullity" in May, Cumhuriyet and Başka Gazete reported. Özel has since left the CHP and founded YENİ Parti, which held its first congress in Ankara.
Sources
- CHP kurultay davasında karar çıktı. Ekrem İmamoğlu dahil 9 kişiye hapis cezası ve siyasi yasak (NTV)
- CHP’nin 38’inci Olağan Kurultayı davasında karar: Ekrem İmamoğlu dahil 9 kişiye 2 yıl 1 ay ceza ve siyasi yasak (Cumhuriyet)
- CHP Kurultay davasında karar açıklandı! Ekrem İmamoğlu’na siyasi yasak (Sabah)
- Son dakika! CHP’nin şaibeli kurultay davasında karar çıktı: İmamoğlu’na siyasi yasak (Yeni Akit)
- CHP kurultay davasında Ekrem İmamoğlu’na siyasi yasak kararı (Ekotürk)
- CHP Kurultay davasında karar: İmamoğlu’na hapis, Cemil Tugay’a beraat (Velev)
- CHP’nin 38’inci Olağan Kurultayı davasında karar: İmamoğlu dahil 9 kişiye 2 yıl 1 ay ceza ve siyasi yasak (TR724)
- CHP’nin Kurultay davasında karar: İmamoğlu, Aydın ve Yeşiltaş dahil 9 kişiye 2 yıl 1 ay ceza ve siyasi yasak (Başka Gazete)
- CHP kurultay davasında karar çıktı (İstiklal)
- İmamoğlu hakkında, daha önce iki kez beraat ettiği davada 2 yıl 1 ay hapis ve ‘siyasi yasak’ kararı verildi! (BirGün)
- İmamoğlu’na iki kez beraat ettiği davada hapis ve siyasi yasak cezası (Bianet)
- İmamoğlu’ndan Tuzla davasına istinaf başvurusu (Cumhuriyet)
Photo: Dosseman / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons


